Customer Reviews

Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.

  • Mark Priebe
    I was with Geico for years but the switch to a local agent was well worth it.

    “With Simpson’s competitive rates I was able to save money by bundling my home, auto, and boat insurance. I was with Geico for years but the switch to a local agent was well worth it. I have peace of mind knowing that if anything were to happen, that my agent is just a quick direct phone call away. Chris Simpson is the most responsive agent I have ever dealt with.”

  • Avery Manko
    These folks are a real pleasure to work with. I highly recommend them.
  • April D. Weimer
    The price was cheaper and the customer service has been great and very personal!

    “I’ve been very happy with the service, and Erie was recommended from a friend who worked for a lawyer as one of the best companies to work with regarding claims. The price was cheaper and the customer service has been great and very personal!”

  • Teresa Schroat
    Awesome. Just not a better place to go for all your needs.
  • MS
    Best quality of insurance...

    “Best quality of insurance, hard-working people, & exceeding expectations for a great family business.”

  • Monica Saunders
    Homeowners and auto insurance with Old Towne, very satisfied.

    “Homeowners and auto insurance with Old Towne,very satisfied. All I ever have to do is pick up the phone and call. They have always been more than happy to answer my questions. Chris assured me today that my policy includes Roadside Assistance. My checks are on the way for a vehicle lock out and towing cost that I incurred recently.”

  • Bradley Morris
    They've got it all figured out over here.

    “Chris was able to get me a quote well below the quotes I received from other insurance companies and on the same day. They’ve got it all figured out over here.”

  • NB
    Great customer service...

    “Making La Plata a better place to live one insurance policy at a time. Great customer service and not to mention all the staff are attractive. Simpson’s Olde Towne Insurance 4 Lyfe!”

  • Sarah Swann
    Everyone I send to them saves money on their policies!

    “Great insurance company and great people to represent you! Everyone I send to them saves money on their policies!”

  • Chris Austing
    Chris was extremely professional, courteous, and thorough.

    “Chris was extremely professional, courteous, and thorough. I was unhappy with my rising auto insurance policy so we went over a few different options which resulted in switching not only my auto policies, but my homeowner’s and umbrella as well. Couldn’t be happier and hardly had to lift a finger. Call him up, give him a few minutes of your time like I did, and see if he can’t put money back in your pocket.”